Pizzeria New York

Columbus, Ohio’s original and authentic New York style pizza

Order Online View Menu

Pickup & dine-in

Order Today

Pickerington

833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147

Mon: Closed
Tue–Thu: 4pm – 9pm
Fri–Sat: 4pm – 10pm
Sun: 12pm – 9pm

Order Online Call (614) 862-4743 Directions

Blacklick

7950 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Mon: Closed
Tue–Thu: 3pm – 9pm
Fri–Sat: 11am – 10pm
Sun: 12pm – 9pm

Order Online Call (614) 868-3870 Directions

From our oven to your table

The Menu

New York Style

Pizza

Hand-tossed pies, build your own or pick a specialty.

View

Lunch & Dinner

Entrées

Parmigiano, alfredo and spaghetti, all with garlic bread.

View

Salads & Desserts

And More

Wings, subs, calzones, cannoli and cheesecake.

View

Since 1969

A Family Story

When I first arrived from Queens, NY I couldn’t find any authentic NY/East Coast Pizza so I brought my family recipes to the Columbus area. Our family recipe dates back to 1969 and still strong in the Brooklyn/Queens neighborhood.

Locations Menu